> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://melbournestagereview.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Carbon: More than ten per cent incomprehensible
- URL: https://melbournestagereview.com/carbon-more-than-ten-per-cent-incomprehensible/
- Published: 2026-11-18T06:08:33.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-18T06:08:33.000Z
- Description: Pier Lorenzo Pisano’s Carbon has cosmic ambitions and intriguing questions about memory, grief and human consciousness. But does Red Stitch’s Australian premiere bring those ideas to theatrical life, or leave us rather more conscious of our carbon-based backsides?
- Author: Ellen M. Scott
- Tags: Reviews

I've never been particularly fond of Foucault. Not because of what he has to say, but because of the considerable effort he seems to expend making his ideas difficult to understand. According to philosopher John Searle, Foucault once admitted that in France, you needed to be at least ten per cent incomprehensible to be taken seriously. I've always found that a curious admission. Is obscurity an unavoidable consequence of difficult thinking, or does it sometimes become a kind of intellectual performance in its own right? There is, after all, a peculiar pleasure in belonging to the club of people who “get it”. But one does begin to wonder whether the difficulty is serving the argument or merely flattering its authors and enthusiastic admirers.

Theatre, of course, is another matter. I've always had a considerable appetite for difficult plays, and rather enjoy being asked to work things out for myself. I don't mind being bewildered. Sometimes I positively relish it. But I do like to be given something to work with, some reason to keep puzzling away as the mysteries accumulate. A difficult text presents its director with a particular challenge: how to sustain that curiosity through performance, atmosphere, dramatic tension or sheer theatrical invention. Pier Lorenzo Pisano's [*Carbon*](https://www.redstitch.net/carbon-2026?ref=melbournestagereview.com), winner of Italy's prestigious Riccione Theatre Award and currently receiving its Australian premiere at Red Stitch under the direction of Katy Maudlin, is a demanding proposition. Turgid, even. And I found myself wondering whether this particular production might have added another ten per cent incomprehensibility of its own.

The ingredients are promising enough. An encounter with an extraterrestrial intelligence has apparently altered the course of human existence. Two people, identified only as A (Caroline Lee) and B (Pantazi Terzian), sit beneath the lights while A attempts to extract an account of what happened. B remembers fragments. Or thinks he does. The encounter has been recorded, replayed and examined so often that the recordings have begun to replace his memories. What does it mean to remember something when the evidence of its occurrence has become more familiar than the experience itself? An excellent question, and one that psychologists and legal scholars have spent decades trying to answer.

![Caroline Lee, dressed in a grey suit, gestures while speaking to Pantazi Terzian, seated opposite in a grey tracksuit, on a warmly lit stage framed by curtains.](https://storage.ghost.io/c/4e/1d/4e1d8918-61fe-47b0-a53e-03b9c2038472/content/images/2026/11/Carbon_Red-Stitch_Caroline-Lee-and-Pantazi-Terzian.photo-Sarah-Walker-0446.jpg)

Caroline Lee as 'A' and Pantazi Terzian as 'B' in the Red Stitch production of Carbon. Photo: Sarah Walker

A asks. B doesn't know. A tries another approach. B still doesn't know. Occasionally some new detail emerges, only for the conversation to return to its original state of uncertainty. There is a discernible logic to this. A wants a coherent account of an experience that may have rendered coherence impossible. B's uncertainty is not merely an obstacle to the investigation; it is, in some sense, the subject of the play. Fair enough. But how many times can we return to the same uncertainty before it loses its fascination? Beckett understood that the failure to arrive anywhere could be magnificent theatre. Here it begins to resemble a clerical procedure, albeit one conducted at the outer limits of human knowledge.

What interests me is how we can see the relationship between A and B changing without quite feeling what brings those changes about. There are moments of resistance, frustration and apparent revelation, but the emotional steps between them seem to be missing. Perhaps we're meant to experience B as A does – an unreliable witness whose account must be patiently reconstructed; or A as B does – an irritating mosquito of the government machinery, buzzing around an experience she cannot possibly understand. It's an intriguing arrangement, placing us in the uncomfortable position of both interrogator and interrogated.

The setting is no less peculiar. Anna Cordingley's exquisite undulating velvet curtains and warm orange lighting suggest a television studio, perhaps an unusually tasteful game show from the 70s, while A's relentless questioning points towards a quasi-military interrogation. I spend a considerable portion of the evening trying to reconcile these competing visual propositions. Is the interrogation itself some kind of performance? The possibility doesn't lead very far. It's a striking departure from Pisano's original Milan production, with its eerie green lighting and translucent cylindrical enclosure surrounding a circular table. Quite why our Australian premiere has traded this unsettling, almost clinical environment for the cosy trappings of retro television is anyone's guess. I remain baffled.

Relief arrives in the form of Voice, played by Conor Leach, who periodically interrupts proceedings to consider humanity's place in the universe. Here, the production discovers some theatrical appetite. Images from the Voyager Golden Record become occasions for amused speculation about the extraordinary difficulty of explaining ourselves to an intelligence that knows nothing of us. Elsewhere, Voice invites us to consider the immense history of the planet, the recycling of matter through countless forms of life, and the absurdly narrow portion of that history to which human beings devote their attention. We are creatures of extraordinary cosmic inheritance who spend an inordinate amount of time worrying about what happened last Tuesday.

![Conor Leach, wearing glasses and holding a microphone, gestures towards projected illustrations during a performance of Carbon at Red Stitch Actors’ Theatre. ](https://storage.ghost.io/c/4e/1d/4e1d8918-61fe-47b0-a53e-03b9c2038472/content/images/2026/11/Carbon_Red-Stitch_Conor-Leach-and-Caroline-Lee.photo-Sarah-Walker-0454.jpg)

Conor Leach as Voice in the Red Stitch production of Carbon. Photo: Sarah Walker

We are, Voice suggests, made of “carbon and nonsense”. It's a lovely formulation, simultaneously ridiculous and rather apt. And these passages have something the central interrogation conspicuously lacks: an imaginative means of bringing abstract ideas into contact with ordinary human experience. I begin to wish Voice would take over the evening altogether.

There is a potentially affecting story beneath all this. B's account gradually reveals a personal tragedy, complicated by the possibility that his encounter has given him access to competing versions of reality. Among them lies the chance to undo his loss, although at a cost that may extend far beyond himself. The extraterrestrial encounter has awakened in B a new solidarity with carbon-based life, now in direct conflict with his most desperate personal longing. Here is the play's central contradiction: creatures made from matter that has circulated through the universe for billions of years remain desperately attached to the fleeting arrangements of that matter we call our lives. We know everything changes. We cannot bear that it does.

But understanding the enormity of B's choice is not the same as feeling its weight. By the time *Carbon* reveals what is at stake, I've been given so little opportunity to feel close to B that his predicament remains curiously remote. Even some startlingly beautiful lighting towards the conclusion, courtesy of Richard Vabre, cannot quite persuade me to feel what I've spent so long trying to understand.

And around me, the audience continually stirs. There is coughing, fidgeting, the unmistakable rustle of people adjusting themselves in their seats. It would be presumptuous to diagnose the collective mood, but there is something wonderfully unfortunate about a production devoted to the mysteries of carbon-based consciousness making its spectators so acutely conscious of their carbon-based backsides.

And yet, afterwards, I find myself thinking about B's impossible choice, about the absurdity of loving one particular arrangement of carbon atoms more than all the others in the universe. About how little consolation there is in knowing that matter survives us. I find myself returning to Foucault, and that troublesome ten per cent. I don't begrudge a play its mysteries. But I do wonder how much of the difficulty here belongs to Pisano's writing, how much has been added in the telling, and whether the two have conspired to make something so fascinating to contemplate considerably less fascinating to watch.

---

[*Carbon*](https://www.redstitch.net/carbon-2026?ref=melbournestagereview.com) plays at [Red Stitch Actors’ Theatre](https://www.redstitch.net/?ref=melbournestagereview.com) until 6 December 2026.

---

Disclosure: A complimentary ticket to *Carbon* was provided to Melbourne Stage Review for the purpose of review. We retain full editorial independence.